There is a new law in Arizona that took effect on January 1 of this year. The law punishes business owners who knowingly hire individuals who don’t have valid legal documents to work in the United States. Penalties include a ten day suspension of a business license for the first offense, and loss of the business license for the second offense. We already have laws in place that prohibit the hiring of illegal aliens. The new law brings the hammer down on businesses that knowingly break that law. It is a good law.
But what will be the effect on our neighbor to the south, the Mexican state of Sonora?
[San Luis Rio Colorado, Mexico Mayor Ruben] Espino said the city will need financial assistance from Mexico’s federal government to handle the anticipated influx of immigrants, who sometimes remain homeless in cities across the border from the United States after their deportations.
Espino and officials in other Mexican border cities have predicted the Arizona law will cause a reverse wave of migration. [source]
I think that “reverse wave” a good thing, and a lot of Arizonans agree.
Arizona has contributed to the education, health care, social services, and police services of illegal immigrants for far too long. I’ve waited in the emergency room for 4 hours before waiting to be seen by a doctor… and I can guarantee that many of the people ahead of me were not legally here. I’m sorry if Mexico feels that it can not provide for their own citizens, but what makes them think that we want to?
-Brooke Lorren, Apache Junction, AZ
I’m not obligated to take care of the family that lives next door to me, why should I be expected to take care of the people who live in the next country over? I’m happy to do what I can for my neighbors, especially if they’re in trouble, but if I find them breaking into my house to grab a snack and a shot of nyquil I’m going to throw their asses out and go get better locks. Most people would do the same. Why would we act any differently on a national level?
A delegation of nine state legislators from Sonora was in Tucson on Tuesday to say Arizona’s new employer sanctions law will have a devastating effect on the Mexican state.
At a news conference, the legislators said Sonora - Arizona’s southern neighbor, made up of mostly small towns - cannot handle the demand for housing, jobs and schools it will face as illegal Mexican workers here return to their hometowns without jobs or money. [source]
“What do we do with the repatriated?” he asked. “As Mexicans, we are worried. They are Mexicans but they are also people - fathers and mothers and young people with jobs” who won’t have work in Sonora.”
He said the Arizona law will lead to “disintegration of the family,” as one “legal” Mexican parent remains in Arizona and the other returns to Mexico. [source]
Oddly enough, this new law doesn’t require anybody to stay in the United States. If my wife had to leave the country for some reason, you’d better believe I’d be right by her side.
It all comes down to the root cause of the problem; criminal activity. If a man is in the country legally, and his wife sneaks across the border (a criminal act) then it’s hard for me to blame anybody other than her for breaking the law. Did she have a strong motivation to break the law? Yes. Does that exempt her from the consequences for breaking that law? No. If there’s any “disintegration of the family” taking place, the fault lies with the person or people that broke the law. If I were to rob a bank and go to prison I would be separated from my family and it would be my own fault for breaking the law.
Mexico is free to complain about all the “migrants” going back to Mexico, but I have no sympathy. Illegal immigration is a problem, and it has been for a long time. It’s about time Mexico got to taste the fruit of the seeds they’ve been cultivating for so long.